728 X 90

How Natural is Too Natural?

By Jenell — July 09, 2012

By JESSICA C. ANDREWS of NewYork Times

When Patrice Grell Yursik began wearing her hair in a wash-and-go style, she got lots of praise. “Women would tell me they wish their hair looked like mine,” said Ms. Yursik, 33, the creator of the blog Afrobella.

While African-American natural-hair advocates of yore, like Angela Davis, embraced a halo of tightly coiled hair, the new “natural” style of choice seems to be longer curls with more definition–which is not always easy to achieve, as Ms. Yursik can attest.

“Many of us have moved beyond the use of harsh chemicals to achieve a different texture, but we’re still walking around with the belief system that led relaxers to such prominence to begin with,” she said.

“The belief that straighter textures and longer lengths of hair are somehow more beautiful comes from what we see around us. Look at the images of black women in the media – if their hair isn’t straight, it’s a very particular type of curly look that’s meant to represent natural hair. It’s another way for the arbiters of mainstream beauty to divide our community.”

When singer Solange Knowles, 26, gave an interview about her hair on Essence.com, this division, referred to as “curlism,” got mainstream attention. Picked up by the popular natural hair blog Curly Nikki, the piece incited vitriolic responses from commenters, who felt Ms. Knowles, whose strands are tightly coiled, was a poor representation of women with natural hair (one person deemed it “unkempt”). “I never painted myself as a team natural vice president,” Ms. Knowles responded on Twitter. “My hair is not very important to me.”

Patrice, founder of AfroBellaPatrice Grell Yursik, the founder of Afrobella.com.
The negative response to kinky Afros is not universal. Viola Davis, 46, elicited a positive response when she wore her TWA, or “teeny weeny Afro,” as the look is known, on the red carpet at the 2012 Academy Awards. Christina Brown, 25, a social media specialist who founded the natural hair blog, Love Brown Sugar, suggested the approval came because “super short ‘fros on the red carpet,” are a rarity. Instead, “we often see this long voluminous curl as a lust-worthy style. It’s a societal norm that’s hard to break,” she said in a recent interview.

Many “naturals” manipulate their hair texture, using methods like twist-outs, braid-outs and Bantu knot-outs to “stretch” the hair and achieve a longer, more defined curl. Nicole Marie Melton of Bronxville, N.Y., an associate beauty editor at Essence.com, doesn’t think this is a bad thing. “Kinky hair that is not stretched is more prone to breakage along the spirals of the hair shaft,” said Ms. Melton, who is 28. “I wear my hair stretched 100 percent of the time because it offers me more versatility and protection from breakage.”

And Ms. Yursik believes that freedom to wear and celebrate one’s hair texture is still at the heart of the natural hair movement. “I think there are some who are in that ‘defined curls by any means necessary’ mind-set,” she said, “but there are also many naturals who still see this as being about freedom, and taking better care of your healthy, strong hair, no matter the texture.”

Chime In!

You might also like:

About Author

Jenell Stewart, formally known as BlakIzBeautyful is the founder and Editor-in-Chief of Kinky Curly Coily Me. Jenell has a MS in special education and dedicates her time to educating and uplifting women with kinky, curly, coily hair. She big chopped on March 26, 2010 and currently lives in Brooklyn, NY.

View all Jenell posts.
  • http://www.facebook.com/profile.php?id=507044948 Amber Isaidit Taylor

    LOL I try telling some hair nazi that hate flat ironing that even twisting and all those products are “manipulating” the hair and therefore is not 100% natural. I’m glad an article finally stated it. I’m firmly in team “mind your own business” as long as it’s perm free, texturizer free etc then ANYTHING else is natural to ME

  • Lyss152

    i dont see how keeping your hair stretched helps prevent breakage. it seems it would have the opposite effect no?

    • http://www.facebook.com/profile.php?id=714055343 Rasheika A. Martin

      Keeping your hair stretched does prevent breakage because when the hair is in its shrunken, tightly coily state, it is MUCH more likely to curl and coil on itself leading to knots and tangles. As we know, knots and tangles lead to breakage. If the hair is stretched it reduces the likelihood of knots and tangling and therefore breakage.

    • killahkurlz

      When its stretched, its unshrunken so it wnt curl around itsself creating ssk and regular knots and tangles

  • http://www.fabellis.com/ Miss FabEllis

    This is interesting.  I definitely think that some people focus entirely on what they define as the “grade of hair” more than the beauty of being natural.  Some constantly say they won’t go natural because they don’t have the “good hair.”  I wish more people would just grow to accept THEIR hair and realize the beauty in it.  Also, I definitely love stretching my hair only for the versatility.  I can’t do wash and go’s because I need styles that can last up to a week in my hair.

  • Natural Beauty

    Everybody has a different hair texture. The point is to love the texture that you hae and rock it to the fullest no matter if you have hair like Macy Gray or Chili.
    celebrateyournaturalbeauty.blogspot.com

  • candycoatedcashmere

    I must admit that I do feel a tinge of jealous when I see a 3a/b/c haired woman. I’m making progress though because before becoming Natural I would do anything and everything to keep my hair straight. However, now my focus in on growing my hair longer and healthier. I don’t care too much about having 4a/b/c textured hair.

  • onyinyechi uwakwemdike

    as long as there is no relaxer/texturizer/brazilian blowout situation, hair is natural.

  • http://www.facebook.com/OniLuxuryHairExtensions Oni Hair

    Your hair can never bee “too natural”. Kinky hair is the adornment of Queens! Rather your hair is kinky with shrinkage, coily, or even while you are wearing kinky extensions for protective styling, we are fabulous at all times!!!

  • http://twitter.com/TrueNiciSpeaks Nicketria Owens

    I personally twist or braid my hair at night just because I like to so protective styles while i sleep but i have no problem wearing my kinky hair in it’s natural state any where. I figure why go natural if i am to be ashamed of what I was born with. However, I think natural hair is wonderful in any form blow out, flat ironed, twist out, braid out, bantu knot out, it’s all beautiful. Naturally beautiful.

  • kime

    I love this! Yes! Many people think straight is bad, but I don’t
    see them sporting their kinky hair 100%! Some have associated straight hair
    with the “desperation to be white” and manipulating your hair to look
    like someone else is what? Hair is dead, so let’s not use this “healthy
    hair” excuse! I say let people do
    whatever you want to do. Have fun with life and mind your own business, at the
    end of the day, its only hair.

KCCM Naturalistsas!

Share the KCCM Love!


Choose a Category

Get $10 off $50 at Beauty.com!
Beauty.com